Creme Of The Island Restaurant and Juice Bar

Creme Of The Island Restaurant and Juice Bar, located at 436 Rockaway Ave in Brooklyn, presents a dual identity that caters to a wide range of tastes. It's a destination for authentic Caribbean food and, as its name proudly declares, a juice bar. This combination creates a versatile establishment, but customer experiences suggest a visit can be something of a mixed bag, with passionate praise existing alongside serious criticism.

The Caribbean Culinary Experience

The restaurant's menu is rooted in island flavors, and for many patrons, it hits all the right notes. Dishes like oxtail, curry goat, and various chicken preparations are frequently mentioned as standouts. One particularly enthusiastic customer, who claims to eat there daily, describes the food as simply "amazing," giving special commendation to the oxtail with peas and rice, salmon with lo mein, and a piece of fried chicken they consider to be "everything." This level of loyalty speaks volumes about the quality and flavor consistency that keeps regulars coming back.

Other diners echo these sentiments, praising the curry goat for being tender and well-seasoned, and the curry chicken for having a pleasant "kick" without being overwhelmingly spicy. The sweet chili chicken also receives specific recommendations. Beyond the main courses, even the side dishes, such as the cabbage, are noted for being delicious. Patrons have consistently described the food as hot, fresh, and flavorful, indicating a commitment to quality in the kitchen.

A Welcoming Ambiance and Service

Positive experiences at Creme Of The Island often extend beyond the plate. Several reviews highlight the staff as being "helpful and sweet" and the overall ambiance as "clean, spacious, and welcoming." For many, the combination of good food and a pleasant environment makes it a recommended spot for anyone in the area seeking a satisfying Caribbean meal. The establishment offers a full range of service options, including dine-in, takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup, adding a layer of convenience for all types of customers.

Points of Contention and Concern

Despite the glowing reviews, not every customer has had a positive experience. A significant point of criticism comes from a review detailing profound disappointment with portion sizes. This customer alleges paying $14 for what they described as merely two pieces of meat, with the container being filled predominantly with rice. This account stands in stark contrast to the otherwise generous feedback and raises questions about consistency. For a potential customer, this suggests that the value proposition might vary.

Even more troubling is the same reviewer's account of a payment issue. They claim to have received foreign currency as part of their change and felt that the staff's reaction was dismissive when it was pointed out. This is a serious allegation that introduces a level of caution for new visitors. While it appears to be an isolated report among the available reviews, it's a significant concern that prospective diners should be aware of, perhaps encouraging them to double-check their transactions before leaving.

The Juice Bar and Healthy Options

An integral but less-discussed aspect of the business is its function as a juice bar. This dual offering is a major asset, allowing Creme Of The Island to serve customers seeking both a hearty, traditional meal and those looking for something light and revitalizing. One of the most compelling endorsements comes from a customer who calls it the "best vegetarian food in the neighborhood," describing the offerings as healthy, fresh, and delicious. This highlights a crucial part of their menu that caters to a health-conscious clientele.

While specific juice and smoothie options aren't detailed in the customer feedback, the presence of a dedicated juice bar suggests a selection of fresh juice and healthy smoothies. This positions the establishment as a one-stop shop where a group or family could satisfy different dietary preferences simultaneously—one person enjoying a rich oxtail stew while another opts for a natural fruit juice or a vegetarian plate. This versatility is a significant advantage in a competitive food market.

Operational Details for a Potential Visit

Planning a visit to Creme Of The Island requires attention to its unique operating schedule. The restaurant opens bright and early at 6:00 AM on most weekdays and Sundays, making it an excellent option for an early breakfast or to pick up lunch for the day. However, it closes early on Fridays at 4:30 PM and is closed entirely on Saturdays. This schedule is crucial for potential weekend customers to note to avoid disappointment.

Final Considerations

Creme Of The Island Restaurant and Juice Bar is a complex establishment with a strong base of devoted fans who praise its flavorful Caribbean cuisine, clean environment, and friendly service. The menu's highlights, from tender curry goat to perfectly fried chicken, have earned it a loyal following. Furthermore, its offerings of healthy vegetarian options and its role as a smoothie bar broaden its appeal significantly.

However, prospective customers should also consider the reported inconsistencies. The concerns raised about portion control and the serious allegation regarding a payment discrepancy cannot be ignored. These issues suggest that while the potential for an excellent meal is high, experiences may vary. For those intrigued by the promise of authentic island flavors and fresh juices in Brooklyn, weighing these glowing positives against the notable negatives is the best approach to deciding whether Creme Of The Island is the right choice for their next meal.